New York Islanders and Pittsburgh Penguins Prediction for 10/9/2025 NHL Picks, Best Bets & Odds

Home » New York Islanders and Pittsburgh Penguins Prediction for 10/9/2025 NHL Picks, Best Bets & Odds
  • Matchup: New York Islanders vs Pittsburgh Penguins
  • Date: Thursday, October 9, 2025
  • Venue: PPG Paints Arena, Pittsburgh, PA
  • Broadcast: Sportsnet Pittsburgh
  • Betting Odds: Islanders (-275) Penguins (+220)

This page may include affiliate links at no extra cost to you, thanks for your support.

On Thursday, the PPG Paints Arena will host a clash between the Pittsburgh Penguins (34-36-12 from last season) and the New York Islanders (35-35-12 from the previous year). The betting odds favor the Islanders at -275, while the Penguins are listed at +220. The total goals for the game is set at 6.5.

nhl picks Anders Lee New York Islanders nhl picks

The New York Islanders aim to bounce back after suffering a 6-1 defeat against the Blue Jackets in their last matchup. During that game, New York spent 2 minutes in the penalty box and struggled offensively, managing to score only once on 37 shots with one power play opportunity.

While playing at even strength, the Islanders conceded 207 goals against their 196. Last season, their opponents had 180 power play chances (ranking 31st in the league) and scored 50 goals. Regarding their offensive performance, the Islanders netted 222 goals (27th in the league) and allowed 257. With 2,418 shots taken, they achieved a shooting percentage of 9.2%. The Islanders finished the season with 82 points, demonstrating a points percentage of .500. They faced 2,356 shots defensively and boasted a save percentage of .891, with 207 power play opportunities resulting in 26 goals, translating to a 12.56% success rate.

In goal for the Islanders will be Ilya Sorokin. Over his professional career, Sorokin has allowed 634 goals, with a goals-against average of 3.34 across 253 games. His save percentage stands at .916 over 11,403 minutes played, with a career record of 125-89-36 and 248 starts. Sorokin has achieved 165 quality starts, boasting a quality start rate of .665, facing 7,561 shots and making 6,927 saves.

In their last outing, the Penguins faced the Capitals, securing a 5-2 victory. Pittsburgh converted 1 out of 2 power play opportunities and found the net 5 times from 38 shots.

During even-strength play, the Penguins scored 185 goals and added 57 goals on the power play (ranking 8th overall). Pittsburgh attempted 2,323 shots (15th in the league) with a shooting percentage of 10.42%, while their opponents took 2,470 shots against them. The Penguins ended last season with 242 goals, 80 points, and a points percentage of .488, conceding 287 goals—239 at even strength and 48 while short-handed. With 221 power play opportunities at a 25.79% success rate, they achieved a penalty kill percentage of 77.78% against 216 power plays, finishing with a save percentage of 88.4%.

Tristan Jarry is expected to guard the net for the Penguins. He has achieved 7,568 saves out of 8,323 shot attempts, resulting in a save percentage of .909. Jarry holds a career record of 152-97-31, playing in 293 games with 281 starts and logging 14,544 minutes. His quality start rate is 59.1%, with 166 quality starts throughout his career. On average, opposing teams have scored 3.11 goals per game against him, with a total of 755 goals allowed.

Which team will clinch the victory in tonight’s NHL matchup? Will it be against the spread or the moneyline?

Pick: Opt for Pittsburgh (+220)

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up or make a purchase through them, we may earn a small commission always at no extra cost to you. Thanks for helping us keep this site running.

Pick: Pittsburgh Penguins (+220)
Bet Now

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

New Bookmakers
Bet99

Proud Partner of the NHL + Excellent live betting

 

Betway

Widest Range of Betting Options + Robust in-play with streaming

BetMGM

Top-Rated Betting App in Ontario with Live streaming & Cash-out

Sports Interaction

Crafted for Canada’s Bettors. Best Odds For NHL, CFL & NFL

© 2025 BettingEdge.ca. All Rights Reserved. BettingEdge.ca is your trusted source for Canadian sportsbook reviews, betting tips, and responsible gaming resources. Must be 19+ to bet. Play responsibly.