- Matchup: Cleveland Guardians vs Boston Red Sox
- Date: Tuesday, September 22, 2026
- Venue: Fenway Park, Boston, MA
- Broadcast: NESN
- Betting Odds: Cleveland (+120) Boston (-144)
This page may include affiliate links at no extra cost to you, thanks for your support.
The Boston Red Sox (84-72) are set to host the Cleveland Guardians (81-75) at Fenway Park this Tuesday. The moneyline for this matchup has the Guardians at +120, while the Red Sox are favored at -144. The over/under for runs is set at 8.5. Pitchers Parker Messick and Payton Tolle will take the mound for their respective teams.
The Guardians have a slugging percentage of .377, with 1,233 strikeouts and 548 walks this season. They have scored 622 RBIs and logged 1,238 hits, contributing to a team batting average of .238. Cleveland has managed 241 doubles and 152 home runs, totaling 649 runs earned and an on-base percentage of .315. Thus far, they average 4.2 runs per game, ranking 26th in the MLB.
The Guardians possess a team ERA of 3.78 (8th in MLB), having struck out 1,476 batters this season. The pitching staff has allowed 169 home runs and 647 runs (also 8th in the league), with 513 walks and a FIP of 3.82. Cleveland has given up 1,232 hits at a rate of 8.0 per 9 innings, totaling 582 earned runs. Their strikeout-to-walk ratio stands at 2.88, and they have a WHIP of 1.26 as a unit.
The Guardians bullpen has a save rate of 73.3%, having entered 170 save situations with 44 successful saves and 16 blown saves. They have inherited 257 base runners this season, with 28.4% scoring. Relievers have appeared in 162 games with runners on base and 166 high-leverage situations. With 532 relief appearances so far this season, the bullpen has secured 108 holds (2nd in MLB).
So far, the Cleveland Guardians have recorded 4,157 putouts, 1,213 assists, and 81 errors, giving them a fielding percentage of .985, which ranks 17th in baseball. The team has turned 101 double plays and has managed to convert 69.3% of balls in play into outs over 12,471 innings, placing them 23rd overall.
Parker Messick has pitched 217 innings, achieving 224 strikeouts in his professional career. He holds an ERA of 2.61 (allowing 63 earned runs), with a WHIP of 1.091 and 184 hits against him (7.6 hits per nine innings) alongside 53 walks. With a career record of 15-10, Messick’s FIP stands at 2.57, having faced 876 MLB batters thus far.
The Boston Red Sox have an on-base percentage of .320 and a team batting average of .246 this year. With 1,271 strikeouts (20th in the league), they have achieved 1,286 hits. Collectively, Boston has hit 161 home runs and accumulated 648 RBIs. Their team SLG% is .401, averaging 4.35 runs per game (20th in the MLB). They’ve doubled 277 times and drawn 497 walks, scoring a total of 678 runs.
The Red Sox pitching staff has allowed 598 runs, compiling an ERA of 3.59 (553 earned runs allowed). They have given up 150 home runs, averaging 3.88 runs per 9 innings (4th in the league). Boston boasts a team WHIP of 1.235, with a FIP of 3.67 for the season. They have a strikeout-to-walk ratio of 8.80 (1,352 strikeouts against 453 walks), ranking 14th in total hits allowed with 1,259.
With 152 save situations, the Red Sox have collected 92 holds and 14 blown saves. Their bullpen has entered 58 save opportunities, recording 44 saves. The inherited runner scoring percentage for Boston bullpen pitchers is 29.4% out of 160 inherited base runners. They have appeared in high-leverage situations 142 times and with runners on base 121 instances, ranking 3rd in MLB with a 75.9% save rate. The team has dispatched 472 relievers to the mound this season.
Over 12,474 innings, the Red Sox have maintained a defensive efficiency of 69.4% (21st in the league). With 118 double plays, they have a fielding percentage of .986, placing them 15th among MLB teams. The Red Sox have recorded 1,361 assists, 79 errors, and 4,158 putouts this season.
Payton Tolle, with a career record of 9-7, has an ERA of 3.34, surrendering 7.5 hits per nine innings. His strikeout-to-walk ratio is 4.02, having faced 649 hitters in his career. Tolle has allowed 59 earned runs, holding a WHIP of 1.125 and a FIP of 3.3. Throughout his career, he has given up 133 hits, amassing 185 strikeouts over 159 innings.
Which team will prevail tonight in the MLB matchup against the spread or moneyline?
Prediction: Bet on Cleveland (+120)
Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up or make a purchase through them, we may earn a small commission always at no extra cost to you. Thanks for helping us keep this site running.
